Tuesday, December 22, 2009

MUTUA STATEMENT

The Government wishes to clarify that arising from a meeting between H.E. President Mwai Kibaki with Hons. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta, Minister for Agriculture, Hon. William Ruto and Minister for Lands, Hon. James Orengo, the Government has allocated 1 billion Kenyan shillings for the purchase of land to resettle two groups that have stopped occupying state forests.


The two groups are 2,800 people from Mau forest and 2,900 people from Cherangany Hills forests. This allocation is in keeping with the Government policy of resettling citizens who have had to leave their homes and are living in despicable conditions.


Dr. Alfred N. Mutua, EBS
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS SECRETARY/
GOVERNMENT SPOKESMAN
22nd December, 2009

Muturi Answers Onyango

On behalf of the Deputy Prime Minister I would like to state as follows:-

Dennis Onyango’s statement on the Mau compensation raises certain issues that need to be addressed as follows:-
1. The Deputy Prime Minister Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta has only publicly discussed the issue of the Mau on two key occasions:-

(a) At a fundraising to raise money to settle those displaced by the evictions from the Mau, where he attended in his personal capacity. What he said at the fundraising was that there was no need to add more tents when we are trying to remove others. The purport of his statement was that there was no need to have more displaced persons living in tents as we already were trying to deal with the settlement of the current IDPs. The statement is a matter of public record.

(b) When he was responding to a media story that gave the impression that the government intended to pay out large sums of money as compensation to large landholders. He was categorical that no arrangement had been made nor any discussion entered into for any payment by the government. The government has not made any budgetary allocation for the payment of any compensation for landowners of any kind. He made the statement as the public were concerned and he was reassuring them that no arrangement as alleged had been entered into, and that is the position.

2. The Deputy Prime Minister Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta has never attacked any policy of the government on Mau at any time

3. The matter of resettlement of Mau evictees has been discussed by government, on humanitarian grounds, but there has been no discussion on compensation on large landholders, there is no contradiction in this regard.

4. The Deputy Prime Minister Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta has never at any time tried to play politics with the issue of Mau, and the allegation is not only baseless and unsustainable, but is in itself playing politics with Mau.




5. The ministry of Finance has not entered into consultations nor discussions with large land owners nor has he received any communication from any government department for any valuation or intent to pay large land owners. Further we have not factored any such payments into the current budget

In conclusion the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister and the Minister for Finance would wish to inform Kenyans that it is committed to maintaining macro-economic stability and implementation of sound financial management principles and policies. In this regard, the Ministry has and will remain focused on committed government programmes of which compensation of large land owners is not one of them

The Prime Minister is a principal in the coalition government and if Dennis Onyango has any reason to doubt a government statement issued in consultation with other government departments, he should not have responded through the media but should have done so through laid down government procedures.


Njee Muturi
Principal Liason Officer
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister and the Minister for Finance
22nd December, 2009

MAU STATEMENT

The Ministry of Forestry and the Ministry of Finance yesterday denied knowledge of any plan to pay compensation to large landowners evicted from the Mau Forest, as reported in the media.

The two ministries stated that the Mau issue was being handled by a secretariat in the Prime Minister’s office – attempting to give the impression that the PM alone would know of or author such compensation plans.

A section of MPs have also apparently expressed dismay at the idea of large landowners being compensated.

As most Kenyans are aware, there is a political game being played here.

In the interest of truthfulness and accountability and on behalf of the Prime Minister, I wish to state the following:

1. The plan to compensate landowners in the Mau was passed by Parliament, following an amendment to the Bill adopting the Report of the Government’s Task Force on the Conservation of the Mau Forest Complex, laid in the House on Wednesday, 12th August, 2009.

In its original form, the Task Force Report had contained no provision for compensation.

But an amendment introduced by the Hon Ekwe Ethuro, after weeks of lobbying by a section of MPs, made it mandatory that conservation of the Mau Forest be effected in line with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, Cap 295 of the Laws of Kenya, and the Registered Land Act, Cap 300 of the Laws of Kenya.

That amendment, sponsored by the lobbying MPs and passed in the House, introduced payment for all title-holders, no matter how their titles had been acquired.

Unfortunately, the amendment these MPs introduced and lobbied for was driven not by the national interest but by irresponsible personal and political motives against the Prime Minister.

The Prime Minister’s position was, and has always been, that Kenyans cannot pay, and should not pay, for land irregularly acquired.
But he has always felt that the small landowners, with a maximum of 5 hactres, who bought it genuinely believing the land was legally on sale, be paid back their money as long as they can prove ownership and that money actually changed hands in the transaction.

It is therefore shamefully dishonest for certain MPs now to attempt to shift responsibility for this situation to the Prime Minister – when they know full well that it was they themselves who introduced, lobbied for and passed this legislation.

At the time they did so, a parliamentary grouping that saw the Mau issue as a platform for political mileage was taking shape.

Members of that ‘alliance’ had already attempted to kill off the entire Mau report. When that did not work, they single-mindedly voted for blanket compensation for all title-holders, large and small alike, whether the titles were legally or illegally acquired.

And with that vote, those MPs committed Kenyans to looking for money for Mau compensation that our country, devastated by drought and food shortages, cannot afford.

(For ease of reference, I attach the Hansard Report on the debate in Mau, showing how MPs committed Kenyans to this pay plan.)

As debate had raged in the House, the Ministry of Finance failed to rise to the occasion and state categorically that the proposed amendment had immense budgetary implications.

But neither the Finance nor the Forestry ministry can now turn round and claim that they are unaware of this amendment and its financial implications.

2. There are serious contradictions in the Finance Minister’s claims that he is looking for money to compensate and resettle those who have been removed from the Mau – but he has no plans to pay large landowners.

The Prime Minister’s position has always been that those who have left the forest so far were encroachers, with no legal claim to the land they occupied. Even the amendment in Parliament did not cover them. But he wanted some humanitarian assistance for them, so that they can restart and rebuild their lives after leaving the forest.

But the Ministry now wants to compensate these people, who have no legal claim to land they occupied – and yet, despite Parliament’s amendment, it wants to pay nothing to those who do have title deeds.

Again, these contradictions emanating from the Finance Ministry amount to nothing more than political chicanery.

The position taken raises serious questions about the Rule of Law and about the use of public funds for partisan or political gain.

It raises even more serious questions about the way Parliament is being used as a plaything by a certain section of MPs.

Kenyans are tired of being taken for a ride. They are tired of losing out while those in a position to save them play politics for their own personal ends.

Our country will never find solutions to its problems while these irresponsible games are allowed to continue.

Thank you.
DENNIS ONYANGO
DIRECTOR OF COMMUNICATION
OFFICE OF THE PRIME MINISTER.
22.12.2009.

MAU WARS

A fresh row is looming in the Cabinet with Prime Minister Raila Odinga accusing his Deputy Uhuru Kenyatta of political mischief, hours after he and Forestry Minister Noah Wekesa denied knowledge of a Sh2 billion compensation plans for Mau landowners.

In a strongly worded statement, the Prime Minister said on Tuesday that the plan to compensate all title holders of the Mau was passed by Parliament following an amendment to the Bill adopting the Report of the Government’s Task Force on the Conservation of the Mau Forest, which was tabled in the House.

The Premier said it was regrettable that Mr Kenyatta and Mr Wekesa were now denying knowledge of the said plans.

He explained that the Task Force Report in its original form had contained no provision for compensation but an amendment introduced by Turkana Central MP Ekwe Ethuro made it mandatory that conservation of the Mau Forest be effected in line with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act.

“The Ministry of Forestry and the Ministry of Finance yesterday (Monday) denied knowledge of any plan to pay compensation to large landowners evicted from the Mau Forest. The two ministries stated that the Mau issue was being handled by a secretariat in the Prime Minister’s office; attempting to give the impression that the PM alone would know of such compensation plans,” a statement sent from Mr Odinga’s office read in part.

“A section of MPs have also apparently expressed dismay at the idea of large landowners being compensated. As most Kenyans are aware, there is a political game being played here,” he went on.

Mr Odinga said that it was unfortunate that the amendments in the Bill, which had been introduced and lobbied for by a section of parliamentarians, were not driven by national interest but by personal motives against him.

“It is therefore shamefully dishonest for certain MPs now to attempt to shift responsibility for this situation to the Prime Minister when they know fully well that it was they themselves who introduced, lobbied for and passed this legislation. At the time they did so, a parliamentary grouping that saw the Mau issue as a platform for political mileage was taking shape,” read the statement in part.

The PM also alleged that members of the said ‘alliance’ had already attempted to kill off the entire Mau report; “…when that did not work, they single-mindedly voted for blanket compensation for all title-holders, large and small alike, whether the titles were legally or illegally acquired.”

“And with that vote, those MPs committed Kenyans to looking for money for Mau compensation that our country, devastated by drought and food shortages, could not afford,” he said.

The Prime Minister also accused the Finance Ministry of failing to state categorically that the proposed amendment had immense budgetary implications, even as debate over the water tower raged.

He added that there were serious contradictions in the Finance Minister’s claims that he was looking for money to compensate and resettle those who had been removed from the Mau, but that he had no plans to pay large landowners.

“The Ministry now wants to compensate these people, who have no legal claim to land they occupied and yet, despite Parliament’s amendment, it wants to pay nothing to those who do have title deeds. Again, these contradictions emanating from the Finance Ministry amount to nothing more than political chicanery,” he said.

He added that the position taken by the concerned ministries brought out significant questions about the Rule of Law and about the use of public funds for partisan or political gain.

“It raises even more serious questions about the way Parliament is being used as a plaything by a certain section of MPs. Kenyans are tired of being taken for a ride. They are tired of losing out while those in a position to save them play politics for their own personal ends. Our country will never find solutions to its problems while these irresponsible games are allowed to continue,” said the Prime Minister.

The statement also maintained that the Prime Minister’s position was that Kenyans could not and should not pay for land that was irregularly acquired.

“He (Prime Minister) has however always felt that the small landowners, with a maximum of five hectares, who bought it genuinely believing the land was legally on sale, be paid back their money as long as they can prove ownership and that money actually changed hands in the transaction,” the statement read in part.

Monday, December 21, 2009

Train accident in Kibera

At least four people are confirmed dead after a cargo trained derailed in the sprawling Kibera slums and fell on houses.

Several people are believed trapped in the debris.

The train headed for Kampala Uganda was loaded with cooking oil when it came of the rails and crashed onto buildings.

The cause of the derailment was not immediately known.

Officials from the St. John's Ambulance rushed to the scene and began evacuating the injured.

Police however had a hectic time trying to control the surging crowd that had begun looting the cooking oil from the containers.

Meanwhile the Prime Minister Raila Odinga has sent his condolences to families caught in the train accident.

"It is my hope that the authorities will investigate the circumstances of this tragedy, but heart goes out to the families of those who lost loved ones, and I wish a speedy recovery to the injured," the PM said.

The PM at the same time called for thorough investigations into accident and other train derailments that have taken place around Kibera saying they are becoming too common.

"Both the Government and RVR must look at the operations, maintenance and the tracks of this rail system, the PM said.

The PM said there appears to be a glaring safety failure in the whole rail system.

"Whether human error or system malfunction - and it raises serious questions."We must investigate this accident until we determine why this happened and what must be done to ensure it never happens again and I ask the company to fully cooperate," Mr Odinga said

KAREGA MUTAHI WON'T QUIT

Karega Mutahi on Monday said he will not resign over the alleged misappropriation of Sh9 billion meant for the Free Primary Education by some ministry staff.

Addressing a news conference in his office, Prof Mutahi claimed the alleged scandal was a fabrication of the media saying he had written to Ministry of Finance requesting a Fiduciary Risk Audit on May 15.

He wondered why the same audit has generated the recent negative publicity which he says was as a result of suspension of officers.

He said he was being targeted for trying to break the corruption networks in the ministry.

“I am resigning the day when someone says this man stole a cent or when I realise that I can’t deliver to the learning of the children; if I resign because someone says I resign, then what you are saying is that stop fighting corruption, get out and let our own continue eating,”

“I’m I resigning because I touched a sacred cow or because I am a participant?” I can assure you I have never stolen from anyone - even a cent from the street.”

He explained that the alleged funds had not been lost and said the matter was a mix up in funds allocated into accounts of separate sub sector.

The PS also absolved Education Minister Sam Ongeri of blame in the saga saying he doesn’t approve any ministry level expenditure and should not be held responsible.

Prof Mutahi however insisted that 15 out of the 26 officers suspended over the saga will have to account for some of the imprests they failed to account for.

“The truth of the matter is that there is no money lost it is simply that in the accounting report two lots of money were put under two accounts. The auditors said you can’t do this because the Sh9 billion belongs to school operation and the Sh10 billion belong to learning and teaching materials. So please separate them. There is no confusion this is an accounting error,” he said.

He said as trustees it’s the duty of his ministry to ensure that the money allocated to education programme is properly used.

“Don’t make it look like the ministry is full of people who want to steal from children,” he added.

He said the government and development partners are in talks towards designing of the 2nd phase of the Kenya Education Sector Support Programme (KESSP) for 2010-2015 saying some of the critical considerations have been to address weakness experienced in the first phase.

“Some of the key concerns are how to reach the hard to reach children, how to deal with the growing numbers of secondary graduates who need to transit to tertiary level issues of education particularly at the school level; monitoring and evaluation.”

FPE SCANDAL

Fresh auditors questions have emerged over the use of Sh9 billion free education money amid speculation that President Kibaki will announce changes at the ministry on Monday.

In an audit report, the auditors said they were not sure that the money given to primary and secondary schools as grants to buy books and other teaching materials was used for that purpose.

The auditors were also puzzled by an additional Sh2.7 billion given to 600 primary schools to build classrooms, dining halls and dormitories which appear not to have been requested or needed.

The auditors noted that Sh3.2 million was sent to three schools namely Namaanga, Nabichakha and Chenjeni in Bungoma to pay suppliers for work not done, and payments were made in advance.

The procedure is for schools to first do a needs analysis to establish the exact amount that they need. The auditors said no such assessment seems to have been carried out.

Prof Mutahi, in a phone interview, however, disputed the claims. “The allocation is based on a needs assessment and there is no money that is disbursed without it,” he said.

The auditors want Head of Basic Education, Mrs Leah Rotich, to explain why Sh1.8 million was given to seven private primary schools. “These schools are not eligible for funding by the government,” the audit report says, adding that “they were in private business.”

Mrs Rotich played down the scandals at the ministry, claiming no funds had been embezzled as reported.

Speaking on Sunday when she presided at a graduation ceremony at Kabarnet High School in Baringo central, Mrs Rotich said “the missing Sh100 million was only meant for workshops.”

“The Sh1,020 for every child has not been interfered with in any way,” she said and welcomed the President’s order to KACC to investigate the ministry.

Saboti MP Eugene Wamalwa called for the prosecution of those found to have stolen school money. He was speaking at a funeral in Uasin Gishu.

Public Accounts Committee chairman Bonny Khalwale said his team would get to the bottom of scandals at the ministry.

He claimed more than Sh200 million was given to buy laboratory equipment under what he said were dubious circumstances.

The ministry has admitted Sh100 million was embezzled and officials have leaked selected parts of the audit report, which show widespread misuse of public funds. The picture painted by the full report must be a lot worse.

The President, who flew into the country on Saturday night, was yesterday said to be contemplating action against top education officials.

According to Office of the President officials, who did not wish to be named speculating on what the President might do, Mr Kibaki could sack top officials.

They said the President appeared particularly unhappy that no one was taking responsibility for the poor handling of free school money, and that the officials appeared to be passing the buck.

The auditors do not categorically conclude that the Sh9 billion was embezzled, they nevertheless conclude that “this expenditure is not eligible”.

Sunday, December 20, 2009

YOUNG TUCKS

Kanu has regrouped and this new group of young tucks is likely to form the next government.



Balala, Kalonzo, Uhuru



Balala, Kalonzo, Uhuru, Ruto


Ruto, Balala, Kalonzo



Uhuru, Ruto

Wamalwa, Poghsio, Balala, Ruto



Young Tucks

Dennis Onyango responds to Ruto

In the light of statements made in regard to settlement of those who left the Mau Forest Complex in which the Prime Minister Raila Odinga has been accused by a section of politicians of being insensitive to the plight of victims, I wish to make the following clarification:

Prime Minister Raila Odinga has consulted widely with President Mwai Kibaki on the issue of resettling Internally Displaced Persons in the country, particularly from the Rift Valley, where the bulk of displacements have occurred in the last two decades.

The consensus between the two, in consultation with security and intelligence agencies, is that the issue of landless internally displaced persons runs deeper than the recent relocation from the Mau and poses serious threats to national stability and economic growth unless it is handled with care and utmost professionalism, devoid of grandstanding, quest for political mileage and quick-fix, short term temporary solutions.

Both the President and the Prime Minister are sensitive to the fact that various groups evicted from their homes in the pre and post-election violence of 1991, 1992, 1993, 1997, 2002 and 2007 are still living in some temporary settlements or as squatters in lands they don’t own.
The Principals are sensitive to the fact that victims of 1992 election violence are still camping in Maela where they first took refuge in the compound of the local Catholic Church. Eventually, they began to fend for themselves and are squatting on other people’s lands.

They are sensitive to the fact that those evicted from Olenguruone and Molo are currently scattered allover Nakuru, Naivasha, Laikipia and Nairobi, some in slums, other living off the streets, hoping that the government will one day attend to their plight.

In parts of Kiambu, particularly in the Gatundu section of what constitutes the wider Aberdares forest, thousands of families evicted from Maela, Enoosupukia, Molo and Olenguruone and other parts are squatting, having been dumped at the Kirigiti Stadium in the middle of the night on orders of the government after the 1992 elections. They are hoping for help from the Government.

In Laikipia, Rumuruti and Marmanent areas are filled with squatters who fled or were ferried there after the 1992 election violence.

In Nyahururu Town, Kiamaina slums are filled with evictees from Olenguruone and Molo following past election violence. The problem is felt as far as Borabu in Kericho-Kisii border and Sondu and Muhoroni areas in Nyanza province.

In recognition of the gravity of the problem and the number of victims waiting for justice and resettlement, the President and the Prime Minister agreed that the Ministry of Lands scouts for land that will gradually and in phases, be home to the many people who have found themselves homeless from the 1990s, first due to politically instigated violence and later as a result of efforts to conserve the country’s water towers including the Mau and Kipkurere forests.

Neither the President nor the Prime Minister is acting alone in this. It is not the intention of the President or the Prime Minister that the scouting for land be used to give political mileage to any individual, community or group.

They want it done in a way that does not make one group happy only to create bitterness in the other. They are looking for a package that is fair to all.

The intention is to deal with a matter that they genuinely believe if not handled properly, will compromise Kenya’s stability in the years to come and one that has been ignored for too long.

Insinuations that the Prime Minister is insensitive to the plight of those who left the Mau are therefore out of tune with the spirit in which the government is seeking to resettle IDPs. Those insinuations are founded on the type of politics that created the problem.

The Prime Minister understands the width and depth of the problem. He was there when the problem began systematically in the run up to 1992 elections. Today, as Co-coordinator and Supervisor of government affairs, his eyes are set on a solution that takes care of all; from 1991 to date.

(Dennis Onyango is the Director of Communications at the Office of the Prime Minister)

ODM WAR ON

A section of ODM MPs at a rally in Mvita constituency on Saturday have blamed Prime Minister Raila Odinga for divisions within the party.

Chepalungu MP Isaac Ruto claimed that the premier was using a rule and divide policy to run party affairs.

Mr Ruto stated that the rival ODM faction would continue to fight for the people in Mau, until justice is served.

Eldoret North MP William Ruto meanwhile argued that he was not at war with anyone and was keener on uniting Kenyans.

“Days of chest thumbing are gone and leadership should not be based on having mammoth crowds in rallies but if the people we are leading are happy with our leadership” he stated.

Deputy Prime Minister Uhuru Kenyatta echoed Mr Ruto's sentiments, at the same time urging Kenyans not to be misled by politicians.

“We have wealth but Kenyans are misled by politicians,” he said, adding that he was not aware of the KKK slogan which he says could destabilise Kenyans.

Vice President Kalonzo Musyoka attended the fund-raiser cum rally at the Mvita Primary School, alongside 41 legislators; with six Cabinet Ministers and eight Assistant Ministers.

The Vice President said that Kenyans should keenly monitor their leaders and those who have not performed should be removed in the 2012 polls.

He expressed confidence that Parliament would unanimously agree on the draft constitution, describing the current batch of leaders as reform minded.

There have been major cracks in the ODM party, which have seen a group of MPs led by Mr Balala and Mr Ruto break-off over what they termed as insincerity and betrayal by the Prime Minister.

The PM’s supporters had called for the duo’s sacking during the Tononoka meeting two weeks ago, but the Premier chose a reconciliatory tone and asked the two to return to the party.

Coast ODM MPs allied to Mr Odinga have joined calls to have the Mvita MP sacked for joining a parallel ODM camp, as a section of them sought through intense lobbying, to replace him at the Tourism ministry.

Mr Balala had earlier maintained that he was firmly in ODM as one of the founder members.

Although the Tourism Minister had reiterated that the rally at Mvita Primary School had been planned long before the Premier’s visit, allies close to the coast MP say a major political announcement is expected to come out of it.

Mr Balala said that the fundraiser was in aid of village elders from his constituency, to help them come up with a project that will earn them some income.